8legs: Lucas digne

Your Followed Topics

#1 out of 3

A handball by Lucas Digne inside the box was ruled a free-kick outside the area, denying a potential penalty in the FA Cup clash.
The decision sparked post-match debate as fans and pundits questioned the lack of VAR in the cup clash.
BBC commentary echoed the frustration, with Danny Murphy calling the decision poor and questioning the assistant's involvement.
Newcastle overturned a 1-0 deficit to win 3-1, with Sandro Tonali scoring and Nick Woltemade sealing the win late on.
The match took place at Villa Park in the FA Cup fourth round, featuring two Premier League clubs.
Fans took to X to express their views, with many calling for VAR in the FA Cup.
The match featured a controversial red card incident for Villa’s goalkeeper in the first half.
Newcastle trailed at halftime but surged back to take the lead and secure progression to the fifth round.
The article notes VAR was not used in this fourth-round tie to ensure consistency across matches.
The piece marks the game with a fan-driven narrative about officiating and callouts for VAR across the FA Cup.

Vote 0

#2 out of 3

Rooney joins the criticism of the match officials, calling one decision the worst he has seen in football, in the absence of VAR at Villa Park.
The disputed handball call occurred inside the penalty area, with Rooney arguing it should have been a Newcastle penalty.
Ex-players and managers echoed concerns about officiating, noting offside and missed penalties underscored VAR's absence.
Emery backed VAR as a necessary tool to assist referees during the match, framing it as essential for correct decisions.
Alan Shearer criticized over-reliance on VAR but acknowledged the need for accurate decisions.
Rooney argued emotions remain a part of football, even as VAR controversies persist.
Rooney's comments contribute to the ongoing debate about VAR effectiveness at the highest level.
Rooney criticized the linesman for being in the penalty box and failing to influence the decision appropriately.
The match featured an offside opener for Villa and several refereeing errors highlighted as reasons VAR is essential.
The piece frames Rooney's remarks within a broader call for consistent officiating in the absence of VAR across top-flight football.

Vote 1

#3 out of 3

sports23h ago

The match revived the debate over VAR, with pundits questioning whether removing it improves officiating.
Alan Shearer criticized the officiating team for not making clearer calls and cited VAR’s influence on confidence.
Eddie Howe said VAR affects decision-making, acknowledging both joy of goals and the wish for clarity in rulings.
The piece argues there is no silver bullet; both VAR and non-VAR approaches have drawbacks.
The article notes offside and handball calls were at issue, influencing post-match discussions on officiating.
Howe reflected on the emotional aspect of goals versus the precision of calls in a VAR-influenced era.
The match is presented as a case study in the broader VAR abolition versus accuracy debate in football.
The article cites Willock’s disallowed goal and Abraham’s offside finish as examples of contentious decisions.
Fans’ reactions varied, highlighting a broader tension between spontaneous celebration and technological oversight.
The piece closes by calling for a balanced approach that reduces delays while preserving fairness and emotion.

Vote 0

Unlimited Access

Personalized Feed

Full Experience

By continuing, you agree to the Privacy Policy.. You also agree to receive our newsletters, you can opt-out any time.

Create an account and enjoy content that interests you with your personalized feed

Unlimited Access

Personalized Feed

Full Experience

By continuing, you agree to the Privacy Policy.. You also agree to receive our newsletters, you can opt-out any time.